Prop. 36 Will:

  • ELIMINATE unintended and ineffective life sentences currently imposed for nonviolent, non-serious crimes
  • RESTORE the original intent and core purpose of the Three Strikes law: to keep dangerous and violent criminals behind bars.
  • SAVE $100 million per year to fund schools, prevent crime, and decrease the need for tax increases.

For Relief Under Prop. 36:

We are working closely with Public Defender offices and other service providers throughout the state to provide the best possible assistance for anyone eligible for relief under Prop. 36.

Click here for resources.

Why We Won

When a third striker poses an unreasonable risk

California’s Three Strikes law was designed to impose severe sentences on repeat offenders, yet its original operation swept in people whose latest offence was neither serious nor violent. A person could receive a life sentence after a relatively minor third offence because of earlier convictions, even where the current conduct showed limited danger to the public. Proposition 36 changed that approach while preserving long sentences for specified violent and serious crimes.

The central question in many resentencing applications is whether releasing or resentencing a third striker would create an “unreasonable risk of danger to public safety”. That phrase is important because it does not mean that a judge must predict perfect future behaviour. It requires a structured assessment of whether the person presents an unacceptable risk of committing one of the particularly grave offences identified by California law.

For an Australian audience, the closest point of comparison is the difference between ordinary sentencing discretion and a special rule for persistent offenders. Australian states and territories have used mandatory or extended sentencing regimes in limited circumstances, including Western Australia and the Northern Territory, but there is no single national equivalent to California’s Three Strikes system. California’s test must therefore be understood on its own statutory terms.

The issue also reaches beyond the courtroom. A life sentence removes people from families, workplaces and local communities, while imposing substantial costs on taxpayers. In cities such as Sydney, Melbourne and Brisbane, where housing, transport and daily expenses already place pressure on households, the consequences of a long custodial sentence can be felt across generations. The legal standard matters because it determines who remains imprisoned and who may return under supervision.

What the unreasonable-risk test actually asks

Under Proposition 36, the court does not ask merely whether a person has a criminal record or might commit another offence. The statutory inquiry is directed to whether the person poses an unreasonable risk of committing a “super strike”—a narrowly defined category of exceptionally serious offences. These include crimes such as murder, certain sexually violent offences and specified offences against young children.

That distinction prevents the test from becoming a general prediction of criminality. A judge may consider evidence of past violence, threats, weapons, victim impact, prison conduct and rehabilitation, but the ultimate concern is the risk of a qualifying grave offence. A possibility of shoplifting, drug possession or another nonviolent offence is not automatically enough to justify continued life imprisonment under this particular standard.

The word “unreasonable” also signals that risk must be assessed in context. Every person released from prison carries some statistical risk of reoffending, and the law does not treat every possibility as a reason for permanent confinement. The court must decide whether the level and nature of the risk is sufficiently serious to outweigh the statutory preference for resentencing eligible people.

Eligibility comes before dangerousness

A person seeking relief must first establish that the sentence falls within the resentencing provisions. This normally requires examining the current offence, the prior strike convictions, the sentence imposed and any statutory exclusions. A current serious or violent felony may prevent relief, as may certain prior convictions or aggravating circumstances listed in the legislation.

Only after eligibility is established does the court make the public-safety assessment. This separation is significant. A person can be ineligible without being found dangerous under the unreasonable-risk test, while an eligible person can still be denied relief if the evidence shows an unacceptable risk of a super strike.

Courts may review the full record rather than relying on the label attached to the latest offence. Charging documents, police reports, sentencing materials, prison records, treatment participation and testimony may all help explain what happened. The process is therefore more demanding than checking a criminal-history database, but it remains bounded by the statute rather than being an unrestricted moral judgment.

Evidence that can support a finding of risk

A finding of unreasonable risk should be based on concrete, reliable information. Relevant evidence may include the seriousness of prior conduct, whether violence was threatened or used, patterns of escalation, access to weapons, credible threats against identifiable people and behaviour while incarcerated. A recent disciplinary record can matter, especially where it reflects assaultive behaviour or repeated refusal to comply with basic rules.

The court may also consider evidence pointing in the other direction. Age, physical health, mental-health treatment, substance-use recovery, education, work history, family support and a realistic release plan can all affect future risk. Someone who has completed vocational training, maintained a clean prison record and arranged stable accommodation may present a different risk profile from the same person years earlier.

This is familiar in principle to Australian sentencing practice, where courts often consider rehabilitation prospects, community protection and the individual circumstances of the offender. The difference is that California’s test operates within a particular statutory definition of dangerousness. A court must connect the evidence to the legally relevant risk rather than simply conclude that the person has lived a troubled life.

Why a serious record is not an automatic answer

Three Strikes cases often involve genuinely serious past conduct. That history cannot be ignored, and victims deserve to have the harm of earlier offences recognised. At the same time, a prior strike is not a permanent substitute for assessing present circumstances. A conviction from decades earlier may say less about current danger than recent conduct, treatment progress and the person’s age.

The same caution applies to the latest offence. A nonviolent offence may still reveal serious dishonesty, addiction or disregard for court orders, but it does not automatically demonstrate a likelihood of murder or a qualifying sexual offence. Treating every third felony as proof of extreme future danger would restore the very breadth that Proposition 36 sought to reduce.

The California Supreme Court’s developing interpretation of the phrase is important for this reason. A recent court ruling explained can help readers distinguish a legally supported finding of dangerousness from a general belief that a repeat offender should receive the harshest available punishment.

The role of rehabilitation and release planning

Rehabilitation evidence is most persuasive when it is specific and connected to the risks identified in the record. Completion of anger-management work, sustained sobriety, psychological treatment, participation in education and consistent employment inside prison may all be relevant. The court can ask whether the person understands the causes of earlier offending and has developed practical strategies to avoid repeating them.

A release plan should be equally concrete. It may identify housing, employment, treatment providers, transport, family support and compliance with supervision conditions. For an Australian observer, this is easy to understand through everyday realities: a person leaving prison in Melbourne or Perth would struggle if they had no stable address, no transport to appointments and no income. A credible plan addresses those practical pressures before they become triggers for reoffending.

Age deserves careful attention. Many people sentenced under the original Three Strikes framework have spent decades in custody and are now older than when they committed the conduct that produced their third-strike sentence. Physical decline, reduced impulsivity and long-term institutional adjustment do not guarantee safety, but they can materially change the risk assessment.

Public safety and the cost of overbroad punishment

Public safety is the strongest justification for retaining a demanding dangerousness test. Communities should be protected from people who present a real and unacceptable risk of grave violence. Reform does not require ignoring victims, minimising serious crimes or releasing everyone who has served a long sentence. It requires directing the harshest punishment towards the people for whom it is genuinely necessary.

There is also a public interest in avoiding imprisonment that no longer serves a defensible safety purpose. California spends significant sums housing ageing prisoners, providing medical care and maintaining high-security facilities. The effect reaches labour markets as well: people who remain incarcerated cannot work, support dependants or contribute to local economies. Research on Three Strikes and jobs places that individual legal question within a wider economic setting.

Australian readers may recognise the broader policy tension. A long prison sentence can remove a parent from the workforce, increase reliance on relatives and complicate rent or mortgage payments. In Sydney’s expensive housing market, for example, the loss of one income can destabilise an entire household. Those effects do not override community safety, but they show why a carefully defined standard is preferable to an automatic life term.

How judges should apply the standard

A sound decision should identify the qualifying risk, explain the evidence supporting it and address the evidence of rehabilitation or reduced danger. It should avoid vague statements such as “the defendant has a bad record” or “the community cannot take the chance”. Those conclusions may express concern, but they do not show why the statutory test has been met.

The court should also distinguish between facts proved at trial, reliable information from the record and speculation. A disputed allegation should not carry the same weight as a conviction supported by detailed evidence. Similarly, prison misconduct should be considered in context: an isolated minor infraction is different from a sustained pattern of serious violence.

Judicial reasons are especially important because appellate courts, victims, prosecutors and the person seeking resentencing need to understand how the decision was reached. Clear reasoning can preserve public confidence while ensuring that the statute is applied consistently. It also reduces the chance that an eligible person remains imprisoned simply because the phrase “unreasonable risk” is treated as self-explanatory.

What reform preserves and what it changes

Proposition 36 did not abolish Three Strikes. It narrowed the circumstances in which a non-serious, nonviolent third offence could lead to life imprisonment and created a route for some people already serving those sentences to seek resentencing. Serious and violent offenders remain subject to severe consequences, particularly where the record demonstrates a genuine likelihood of extreme harm.

The reform therefore rests on proportionality as well as public safety. A person should not receive the same legal response for a minor third offence as someone whose latest conduct and history show a continuing capacity for grave violence. The unreasonable-risk standard is the mechanism that separates those cases.

Supporters of reform have also highlighted endorsements from law-enforcement figures and criminal justice advocates who view targeted sentencing as compatible with safer communities. Those perspectives are collected in the organisation’s endorsement record, which reflects the argument that precision can strengthen, rather than weaken, public protection.

A finding that a third striker poses an unreasonable risk should therefore be treated as a demanding legal conclusion, not a slogan. The practical takeaway is to examine eligibility first, connect the evidence to the statutory super-strike risk, weigh present circumstances alongside past convictions, and require clear reasons before continuing a life sentence.

News

Next Slide Previous Slide