Prop. 36 Will:

  • ELIMINATE unintended and ineffective life sentences currently imposed for nonviolent, non-serious crimes
  • RESTORE the original intent and core purpose of the Three Strikes law: to keep dangerous and violent criminals behind bars.
  • SAVE $100 million per year to fund schools, prevent crime, and decrease the need for tax increases.

For Relief Under Prop. 36:

We are working closely with Public Defender offices and other service providers throughout the state to provide the best possible assistance for anyone eligible for relief under Prop. 36.

Click here for resources.

Why We Won

How Three Strikes Shapes California’s Labor Market and Economy

California’s Three Strikes law was designed to impose severe sentences on people with repeated serious criminal convictions. Its reach, however, extended beyond courtroom punishment. By keeping many people incarcerated for decades or life after a third felony, the law also influenced workforce participation, household income, public spending, and the economic health of communities with high incarceration rates.

The labor-market effects are difficult to measure with a single statistic. A person removed from the workforce may have had limited education, unstable employment, or a history of substance use before incarceration. At the same time, long prison terms can prevent people from gaining work experience, supporting children, paying taxes, or contributing to local businesses. The result is an economic impact that reaches families, employers, state agencies, and taxpayers.

Proposition 36, approved by California voters in 2012, narrowed the circumstances in which a third strike could result in a life sentence. It preserved strong penalties for serious and violent crimes while allowing some people convicted of non-serious, nonviolent offenses to seek shorter sentences or resentencing. Examining this change through an economic lens helps explain why sentencing policy is also workforce policy.

Incarceration Removes Potential Workers

A long prison sentence takes a person out of the available labor pool for an extended period. In the short term, that means lost wages and reduced household earnings. In the long term, it can mean years without occupational training, professional contacts, technological experience, or a stable employment record. These absences make reentry harder, especially in industries where credentials and recent experience determine access to jobs.

The impact is especially significant for workers in their prime earning years. A sentence that begins in a person’s twenties or thirties can remove decades of potential employment. When that individual eventually returns to the community, age, health problems, limited digital skills, and a criminal record may reduce the range of available jobs. The economy loses productive capacity while employers lose a possible source of labor.

Incarceration can also affect labor-force participation among relatives. A household may respond to the loss of an income earner by taking on debt, increasing working hours, or leaving the workforce to care for children. Children may experience housing instability or reduced educational opportunities, which can influence their future earnings. These effects are rarely included in the direct cost of imprisonment, even though they shape California’s human capital over time.

Public Spending Has Labor-Market Consequences

Life sentences and lengthy prison terms require public funding for housing, health care, food, security, administration, and legal services. Those expenditures are not economically neutral. Money directed toward prison operations cannot be used for community colleges, transportation, behavioral-health treatment, workforce development, or other programs that can improve employment prospects.

The cost of incarceration also rises as a population ages. Older incarcerated people tend to require more medical care, specialized housing, and support services. A sentencing system that keeps people imprisoned for decades can therefore create long-term obligations for the state budget. Savings from carefully targeted sentence reductions may provide room for investments that address the conditions associated with crime and unemployment.

There are also local economic effects. Prisons provide employment in some communities, so changes in the incarcerated population can affect correctional facilities and nearby service providers. Yet the benefits of prison-related jobs are distributed differently from the costs of incarceration. Families separated by imprisonment may live far from facilities, paying for travel, phone calls, and legal assistance while losing income. A complete economic assessment must account for both regional employment and the broader circulation of money through California communities.

Reentry Determines Whether Reform Pays Off

Reducing an excessive sentence does not automatically produce a job, stable housing, or a successful return to society. The economic value of resentencing depends partly on whether people can reconnect with the labor market. Access to identification documents, transportation, health care, education, vocational training, and sober housing can determine whether a returning resident becomes employed or cycles back into custody.

Employers may benefit from a larger pool of experienced workers, particularly in sectors facing persistent vacancies. Construction, logistics, food production, maintenance, caregiving, and manufacturing often need applicants who can demonstrate reliability and practical skills. People who have spent many years in prison may have developed abilities in culinary work, machine operation, landscaping, janitorial services, or facility maintenance, but those skills require credible documentation and fair hiring practices.

A criminal record remains a barrier even when the original offense was nonviolent and the person has served a substantial sentence. Background checks can exclude applicants before an interview, while occupational licensing rules may limit entry into fields that offer advancement. Policies that support individualized review, record relief where appropriate, and employer education can help California capture the productive value of people who are prepared to work.

Reform Can Align Safety With Economic Stability

The case for reform is strongest when it distinguishes between people who pose a serious public-safety threat and those whose third strike involved a non-serious, nonviolent offense. Proposition 36 retained life sentences for qualifying serious or violent conduct while changing the treatment of certain lower-level third strikes. This approach recognizes that sentence length should reflect both the person’s record and the conduct underlying the latest conviction.

A more proportionate sentencing structure can reduce prison costs without requiring the state to abandon accountability. People who qualify for relief may still face supervision, treatment requirements, restitution, or other conditions. When those conditions are paired with employment assistance, the public receives a better chance of stable reentry than it would from release without support.

The reform’s advocates have documented the human and fiscal consequences of lengthy sentences in discussions of three strikes life sentences. Those consequences matter to the economy because every year of unnecessary incarceration can represent lost earnings, lost family support, and public spending that might otherwise strengthen prevention and employment programs.

Public safety remains central to any economic analysis. Crime can impose enormous costs through medical bills, property loss, business disruption, fear, and reduced investment. A labor-market strategy cannot treat release as the only objective. It must focus on reducing reoffending, protecting victims, and ensuring that people who return to the community have realistic ways to earn lawful income.

Comparing the Economic Pathways

The choices surrounding a third-strike sentence produce different consequences for workers, families, government budgets, and communities. The comparison below is not a prediction for every individual case. It shows the main channels through which sentencing policy can affect economic outcomes.

Economic factor Extended incarceration for a nonviolent third strike Proportionate sentence with supported reentry
Workforce participation Removes a potential worker for many years and interrupts skill development Allows earlier return to employment when public-safety conditions are met
Public spending Creates continuing prison, health care, and supervision costs Can reduce incarceration costs while shifting resources toward reentry
Household finances May eliminate income and increase caregiving, travel, and legal expenses Can restore family earnings and reduce financial strain
Employer access to labor Leaves vacancies unfilled by excluding an experienced working-age adult Expands the applicant pool if employers use fair, individualized review
Tax contribution Reduces potential wage and sales-tax contributions during incarceration Creates an opportunity for earnings, taxes, and consumer spending
Public safety Incapacitates the individual but may provide limited preparation for eventual release Combines accountability with treatment, monitoring, and employment support

This comparison also highlights the importance of timing. A person released after decades may need more intensive services than someone sentenced proportionately from the beginning. Delayed intervention can make rehabilitation more expensive because health needs, family separation, and skill loss accumulate. Sound policy therefore weighs immediate punishment against the future cost of weakening a person’s ability to work.

California’s economic interests are served when sentencing decisions are precise. Reserving the longest penalties for dangerous conduct can maintain incapacitation where it is most justified, while avoiding unnecessary workforce exclusion in cases that do not involve serious or violent behavior. That distinction is the foundation of a more targeted criminal justice system.

Businesses Feel the Effects Through Hiring and Retention

Employers operate within the labor market created by public policy. When large numbers of working-age residents are incarcerated, businesses may face tighter hiring conditions, especially in regions where incarceration rates are high. Recruiting becomes more expensive, turnover can increase, and employers may rely more heavily on temporary labor or overtime.

A record can also create a mismatch between available jobs and available workers. Some people returning from prison possess practical experience but cannot pass an automated screening process. Others may be eligible for work but lack transportation to industrial areas, a phone, or a bank account for payroll. These barriers reduce the effectiveness of labor supply precisely when employers need dependable applicants.

Businesses that use structured, individualized hiring can help close this gap. Reviewing qualifications before conviction history, making job requirements clear, and offering predictable schedules can improve retention. Such practices do not eliminate the need for workplace safety or due diligence. They allow employers to evaluate a candidate’s current reliability rather than treating an old conviction as a complete forecast of future conduct.

Policy Priorities That Connect Justice and Growth

Economic analysis should guide practical investments after sentencing reform. Redirecting a portion of correctional savings toward services can make release safer and improve the likelihood that people will become self-sufficient. Programs should be measured by employment, housing stability, treatment completion, family reunification, and recidivism rather than by enrollment alone.

Useful priorities include:

  • Expand vocational education, digital-skills training, and recognized credentials inside correctional facilities.
  • Provide identification, transportation, housing, and health-care support before release.
  • Build partnerships among employers, community colleges, workforce boards, and reentry organizations.
  • Use individualized hiring and licensing standards that protect safety without imposing blanket exclusion.
  • Track employment, earnings, tax contributions, and reoffending after resentencing.

These measures can also help local governments plan for changing needs. Communities that receive returning residents may need additional behavioral-health care, affordable housing, and job placement capacity. Transparent data can show whether savings are reaching those services and whether public-safety outcomes are improving.

The strongest approach treats employment as part of prevention. A lawful income, stable routine, supportive supervision, and access to treatment can reduce pressures that contribute to repeated offending. Work is not a substitute for accountability, but it is often a critical condition for lasting reintegration.

A More Productive Measure of Public Safety

California’s experience with Three Strikes raises a broader question about how success should be measured. Counting prison years alone says little about whether a policy reduces future harm or strengthens communities. A more complete assessment considers victimization, reoffending, family stability, public expenditure, employment, and the ability of people to live safely after serving their sentences.

Support for targeted reform has come from criminal justice advocates and law-enforcement figures who argue that proportionality can reinforce public safety. Their perspectives are reflected in the range of reform endorsements supporting a distinction between dangerous offenses and nonviolent conduct. Such distinctions allow policymakers to focus the harshest sanctions where they have the clearest safety rationale.

The labor market is one part of that larger evaluation. When people are sentenced for conduct that does not justify permanent removal from society, California may lose workers, consumers, parents, and taxpayers without receiving a corresponding public-safety benefit. When reform is paired with supervision and practical reentry support, the state can pursue accountability while preserving more opportunities for productive participation.

The Committee for Three Strikes Reform provides information about Proposition 36, sentencing relief, public-safety arguments, and the economic stakes of a more focused law. Read the available resources, review the evidence, and sign up for updates to stay engaged with efforts to make California’s sentencing system more proportionate, fiscally responsible, and supportive of safer communities.

News

Next Slide Previous Slide