Prop. 36 Will:
- ELIMINATE unintended and ineffective life sentences currently imposed for nonviolent, non-serious crimes
- RESTORE the original intent and core purpose of the Three Strikes law: to keep dangerous and violent criminals behind bars.
- SAVE $100 million per year to fund schools, prevent crime, and decrease the need for tax increases.
For Relief Under Prop. 36:
We are working closely with Public Defender offices and other service providers throughout the state to provide the best possible assistance for anyone eligible for relief under Prop. 36.
Click here
for resources.
Why We Won
How three strikes reform can change reoffending after release
Three strikes sentencing can make the third conviction the most important event of a person’s life, even when the offence itself is nonviolent and minor. Under California’s existing framework, some people can receive life without parole. The Committee for Three Strikes Reform backs Proposition 36, which seeks to end life imprisonment for qualifying nonviolent, non-serious offences while preserving severe penalties for dangerous and violent criminals. Its central public-safety argument is that long confinement is not the same thing as reducing crime after release.
The issue is rarely the prison door itself; it is what happens in the years after a person comes home. A sentence may end, but housing, employment, health and social ties do not automatically return with the person. This is why the relationship between three strikes reform and recidivism rates must be examined through released cohorts, rather than inferred from the length of a sentence alone.
What the reform actually changes
California’s three strikes scheme can turn a third conviction into life without parole, even when the latest offence is nonviolent and non-serious. Proposition 36 sets a different boundary. It seeks to remove life imprisonment for qualifying low-level offences while retaining enhanced penalties and restrictive parole rules for violent felonies, serious prior convictions and offenders judged dangerous. That narrower group matters: people brought home through resentencing are not a random sample of everyone leaving California’s prisons.
The reform therefore works through both sentencing and resentencing. People convicted under the revised law would not automatically receive life for a qualifying nonviolent third strike, while some people already serving life for eligible offences could seek review. The legal filter around identifying eligible offences is crucial. Defence attorneys must check the offence itself, the sequence of prior strikes and exclusions that can still make a sentence severe. A correct classification is the first step towards a fair release decision.
That classification also shapes any later recidivism calculation. A resentenced group may contain fewer people with serious violent histories than the overall prison population, so its reoffending rate should not be presented as a verdict on every person serving a long sentence. Equally, the reform cannot excuse higher-risk offenders from supervision. It changes who receives an extreme punishment and on what evidence, not the need to manage risk in the community.
Why long incarceration can raise risk after release
Decades in prison can interrupt the ordinary routes towards stable housing and lawful work. It can weaken family relationships, leave qualifications outdated and expose people to institutional habits that make civilian life harder to navigate. These are risk factors, not an automatic prediction. But they accumulate, and they tend to be most disruptive when a person leaves custody with little money, no acceptable address and a health history that has received little attention outside prison.
California’s connection between state recidivism efforts and sentencing policy reflects this wider public-safety picture. Reoffending is influenced by what is available after release, particularly housing, health care, treatment and dependable supervision. People on parole are often required to attend appointments during work hours, obtain documentation they do not have and travel across a large state. A legal order that demands compliance without providing the means to comply can generate technical breaches and return trips to custody.
The financial argument points in the same direction. Life sentences impose years of custody, health care and prison maintenance for offences that often carry little direct danger to the public. Savings can strengthen community corrections if they are reinvested in housing, treatment and parole services rather than simply removed from the books. Release is not a stand-alone solution, though. Shorter terms can produce better outcomes when people have support and clear conditions; they may produce the same revolving door when the support does not exist.
Measuring the change without inventing certainty
Recidivism can mean several things: a new arrest, a new conviction, a breach of parole, a return to prison or a new violent offence. California’s headline measure commonly tracks rearrest or reconviction within three years of release, while technical supervision violations are often counted separately. Any assessment of the reform should state which measure it uses. Falling technical breaches would be a sign of easier adjustment; falling violent reoffending would carry a very different meaning.
There is also a selection problem. If a law releases people with less serious prior records, their measured reoffending will probably be lower than that of a comparable group of released prisoners with more serious histories. That is a public-safety gain, but it does not prove that incarceration itself caused the difference. A credible evaluation should compare eligible people who are resentenced with similarly situated people, account for unequal time at risk in the community and track whether each returns for a new crime.
Evidence from other jurisdictions is useful but bounded. Carefully designed release projects in states such as Colorado and Kentucky did not show a surge in violent offending among the people released, although their samples were small and their offences and supervision arrangements varied. Such findings support the argument that long imprisonment is not automatically necessary for public safety; they do not predict the exact rate under a statewide reform.
A useful evaluation would follow individuals from the court order through release and into the three years afterwards. It would report outcomes by prior record and offence type, not just produce a single statewide percentage. It should separate new crimes from missed appointments and unpaid fees, since reincarceration for a technical breach is not equivalent to committing another offence. Readers can follow news updates for legislative and implementation developments, while keeping that distinction between announcements and evidence in view.
Australian safeguards and measures of success
Australian readers encounter “three strikes” as familiar political language, although the laws are not direct copies of California’s. New South Wales uses the term for escalating penalties in repeat offending, Victoria’s three-strikes sentencing rules act as a catalyst for deterrence, and Queensland provides life imprisonment for repeat offenders in some circumstances. The comparison is useful precisely because the systems differ: offence categories, prior convictions and parole rules matter as much as the label attached to a policy.
The market for release support also works differently here. Community corrections in New South Wales and Victoria is commissioned through government funding contracts involving non-profit providers, including Aboriginal community-controlled organisations in some regions. Practitioner language reflects another local difference: Australian services usually speak of “release planning” or “re-entry”, rather than relying only on the American term “reentry”. Funding pathways and service availability can shape a former prisoner’s chances well before any supervision officer checks in. The practical supports worth funding are straightforward:
- Stable accommodation close to work, transport and treatment, rather than a bed without a tenancy or address.
- Case management that continues substance use treatment, mental health care and family contact after release.
- Employment or training linked to local employers, including flexible options for physical or cognitive impairments.
- Culturally safe support commissioned through Aboriginal community-controlled organisations and local communities.
These supports depend on place. A person released in Parramatta may face different rent, transport and employment pressures than someone leaving custody in Melbourne, while a person returning to Alice Springs may have fewer specialist services within reach. Distance, housing costs and crowded public transport shape whether someone can keep a lawful life between appointments. A credible evaluation should therefore publish several measures of success:
- Rearrest and reconviction rates over three years, reported separately from supervision breaches.
- New violent offences and the offences most associated with the person’s earlier convictions.
- Time to stable housing and the proportion receiving timely treatment or a job.
- Reincarceration for new crimes compared with reincarceration for technical violations.
None of this suggests that sentence length is unimportant. It shows why sentencing changes need to be judged against the circumstances of release. The strongest local lesson is simple: a shortened prison term can improve public safety when it is paired with stable accommodation, treatment and fair supervision. Without those supports, legal eligibility for resentencing may change a prisoner’s status without changing the obstacles outside it.
A safer framework that can be tested
The case for reform combines proportionality with practical public-safety gains. People convicted of nonviolent, non-serious offences should not spend the remainder of their lives in custody because prior convictions trigger an inflexible rule. Equally, severe penalties and careful review must remain for violent or dangerous offending. Proposition 36’s boundary is defensible only if officials apply the exclusions properly and continue to supervise people whose convictions indicate continuing risk.
An effective release package therefore needs more than a court order shortening a sentence. Housing should be identified before release, health coverage should continue without a gap, and community treatment should remain available when parole begins. Supervision conditions must be firm but workable, allowing for shifts, travel and the ordinary difficulties of finding work. Aboriginal clients should be able to access culturally safe services through organisations they choose, while people with disabilities need adjustments that make participation genuinely possible.
These details are not peripheral to recidivism. They affect whether a person can reach a treatment appointment, complete a parole condition, hold a job and avoid the circumstances that led to an earlier conviction. They also affect public confidence: a reform that promises safer communities must be able to show that it has reduced reoffending rather than merely reduced the number of people held in prison.
The concrete next step is for California’s sentencing and corrections agencies to publish a cohort-tracking plan for people approved for resentencing, measuring three-year rearrest and reconviction rates separately from technical violations and recording housing, employment and treatment outcomes over the same period.