Prop. 36 Will:
- ELIMINATE unintended and ineffective life sentences currently imposed for nonviolent, non-serious crimes
- RESTORE the original intent and core purpose of the Three Strikes law: to keep dangerous and violent criminals behind bars.
- SAVE $100 million per year to fund schools, prevent crime, and decrease the need for tax increases.
For Relief Under Prop. 36:
We are working closely with Public Defender offices and other service providers throughout the state to provide the best possible assistance for anyone eligible for relief under Prop. 36.
Click here
for resources.
Why We Won
What a Third Striker Should Know Before Waiving a Resentencing Hearing
California’s Three Strikes law is unlike the sentencing system most Australians know. Under it, a felony conviction can become a “strike,” and a later felony can trigger a life sentence even when the latest offence was nonviolent and the person has no violent criminal record. The phrase “third striker” is therefore misleading if it suggests that every third conviction produces the same outcome.
A decision to waive a resentencing hearing can have consequences that last for decades. The benefit may be eligibility for a shorter sentence; the cost may be surrendering procedural rights that cannot readily be restored. Anyone considering that choice needs a clear account of the conviction history, the statutory eligibility rules and the exact terms of the proposed waiver, followed by advice from a lawyer admitted to practise in California.
What a waiver actually changes
A resentencing hearing is not the same event as sentencing following a jury verdict. It takes place after conviction, when a court considers whether an already convicted person can receive a different sentence. Depending on the legal route, the prosecution participates, the court assesses statutory criteria and the defence may present information relevant to the sentence. It is not an automatic release hearing, and a successful petition does not itself guarantee parole.
The terminology needs care. Waiving the right to have a jury determine a resentencing issue is not necessarily refusing every form of hearing; a judge may still conduct proceedings before imposing a sentence. Some documents also require factual admissions or specify the proposed term. A person should therefore obtain the actual waiver, read its definitions and establish exactly what it covers rather than relying on the phrase “waiving the hearing.”
A knowing and intelligent waiver can produce an opportunity that would otherwise be unavailable. It can also limit later options. A lawyer should compare the proposed resentencing with any available appeal or habeas corpus remedy, explain the likely sentencing outcome and identify whether the agreement is final. The relevant comparison depends on the case file, the court’s jurisdiction and the current law; a general summary cannot supply it.
The limits of Proposition 36
The committee’s materials on Proposition 36 explain the 2012 California ballot reform. Its central aim was to shorten mandatory life sentences for people whose latest conviction was a nonviolent, nonserious felony and whose earlier record did not contain disqualifying serious or violent convictions. It did not abolish Three Strikes or make every nonviolent third felony eligible for an ordinary state prison term. Severe penalties remained for many repeat offenders.
Eligibility turns on statutory classifications, not the impression a charge makes. An offence described in everyday language as technical or minor may fall within a definition that carries enhanced punishment. California Penal Code section 1192.8(d) provides a route for seeking resentencing, but its requirements must be satisfied. The current conviction must qualify, the earlier record must be checked against the statute, and specified exclusions can defeat relief. An initial count from a probation department is a starting point, not a binding determination.
The reform’s public-safety argument is that people unlikely to present a serious danger should be able to complete proportionate sentences in the community while the law continues to protect the public from those who pose a grave risk. Its financial argument concerns the expense of long prison terms and the possibility of redirecting resources towards supervision, treatment and reintegration. Those arguments explain the policy behind the change, but they do not determine whether a particular petition qualifies or what sentence a particular court should impose.
Why the hearing record matters
At a resentencing hearing, eligibility and the proposed sentence can both matter. The court may consider statutory sentencing factors, including qualifying mitigation, before choosing a term. Information about a person’s upbringing, criminal history, rehabilitation and future plans can therefore matter when connected to a recognised sentencing purpose. Counsel must distinguish evidence that can properly be presented from personal details that would not assist the court.
The defence must also confront the prosecution’s version of the predicate convictions. An allegation that a prior conviction qualifies as a serious or violent felony may require proof of the statutory elements, not merely proof that the earlier case ended in conviction. If a prior conviction is disputed, the appropriate procedure may depend on whether the issue can be addressed during resentencing. Charging papers, witness records and transcripts are consequently more valuable than a bare numerical total.
For a case study of a chef whose third strike involved a forgery charge, see the chef’s case. It is a useful reminder that the alleged offence, the earlier record and the court’s legal classification must be examined individually. A person’s occupation or public reputation does not determine eligibility, and one case cannot predict another person’s result.
Checking the prior-offense record
A petition can fail because the prior-offense count is wrong or incomplete. County probation departments prepare information used in charging and sentencing decisions, but their records are not necessarily the final word before a court. The explanation of how prior offenses count provides useful background for understanding that administrative process and the importance of identifying the records the court will consider.
The lawyer should compare charging documents, abstracts of judgment, custody records, dockets and disposition information for each alleged strike. The comparison should address the statutory elements, whether the sentence was completed, and whether any order set the conviction aside. A later dismissal, sealing order or change in case status may affect the analysis. Being told informally that an old conviction “does not count” is not an adequate substitute for checking the source documents.
A person moving from Australia should not import the usual Australian assumption that a completed sentence automatically disappears from the criminal record. California can count certain older convictions, subject to the offence type, lookback periods and other statutory conditions. Counsel should also establish whether a conviction followed a guilty plea, a trial or an admission in court, because the available routes to challenge it can differ. The aim is an accurate chronology, not a larger or smaller account presented to the court.
Why Australian law cannot fill the gaps
California law governs a California conviction, and an Australian criminal record is not interchangeable with one. New South Wales and Victoria both permit life imprisonment with a non-parole period, but their sentencing statutes and appellate rules differ: the Crimes Act 1900 (NSW) and Sentencing Act 1997 (Vic) do not operate as translations of the California statute. There is no single national Australian three-strikes rule that supplies the missing test for a California petition.
Advice is jurisdiction-specific as well. Legal Aid NSW and Victoria Legal Aid provide public legal assistance in their respective states, generally for Australian legal problems rather than California resentencing proceedings. A community legal centre in Sydney, Melbourne or a regional city may assist with a related Australian matter, but its service scope may not extend to California representation. California sentencing requires advice from a California lawyer, just as an Australian matter requires knowledge of the relevant state law.
Ordinary Australian transactions can also expose the gap between familiar facts and foreign legal labels. A dispute involving a Coles or Woolworths self-checkout, a Myki or Opal card transaction, or a sale through eBay Australia or Gumtree may appear minor at the time. If such events lead to an American prosecution, the court will apply California definitions of the alleged offence and the applicable sentencing rules. Australian labels such as fraud, theft or handling stolen goods are not substitutes for those definitions. Receipts, account records and messages should be preserved, while California counsel determines what they establish and how they should be used.
A practical preparation file
A useful consultation begins with documents and a short chronology, rather than a general argument that the punishment is excessive. California statutes, the record of each conviction and the terms of the proposed waiver should be examined together. The following materials help a lawyer test the information without assuming that the hearing is either a guaranteed win or a routine paperwork decision.
- A complete criminal-history record from every California county where a conviction is alleged, together with the relevant case numbers.
- Charging papers, plea forms or admissions, sentencing orders, abstracts of judgment and any probation-revocation documents.
- A dated chronology listing earlier offences, custody and release dates, later convictions, and rehabilitation undertaken since imprisonment.
- Records supporting proposed mitigation, including education, employment, treatment, housing, family support and participation in rehabilitation programmes.
- Every document containing a proposed jury waiver, resentencing agreement, factual admission or other form connected with the hearing.
The legal analysis should then turn to the waiver itself and the alternatives. These prompts help identify what must be established, what rights are being exchanged and what remains available if the proposed agreement does not proceed.
- Whether the current conviction and complete prior record satisfy the statute’s present eligibility requirements.
- The exact rights being waived, including whether a jury would otherwise decide resentencing and whether any admission is required.
- Whether an appeal, habeas corpus review or other remedy remains available, and what deadlines or preservation requirements apply.
- The realistic sentencing range under a qualifying resentencing proposal and the parole consequences of accepting that term.
- The prosecutor’s role, the effect of a denied petition and the evidence that can properly be presented.
The next concrete step is to prepare a one-page chronology, mark each fact as verified, disputed or unknown, and bring it with the complete sentencing file and proposed waiver to a California-licensed attorney before agreeing to a hearing or signing anything.