Prop. 36 Will:
- ELIMINATE unintended and ineffective life sentences currently imposed for nonviolent, non-serious crimes
- RESTORE the original intent and core purpose of the Three Strikes law: to keep dangerous and violent criminals behind bars.
- SAVE $100 million per year to fund schools, prevent crime, and decrease the need for tax increases.
For Relief Under Prop. 36:
We are working closely with Public Defender offices and other service providers throughout the state to provide the best possible assistance for anyone eligible for relief under Prop. 36.
Click here
for resources.
Why We Won
Proving a Prior Strike in a California Court
The proof of a third striker’s prior strike in court depends on the records and statutory findings, not the number of arrests on a page. Under California’s Three Strikes law, a strike ordinarily depends on two earlier convictions that meet the statutory definition of a serious felony. Proposition 36, approved by voters in 2012, created pathways for qualifying people serving life for a nonviolent third felony to seek resentencing or parole review. The process therefore begins with an evidentiary question: which convictions qualify, and can the court verify them from reliable records?
California courts distinguish a conviction from an allegation, a dismissed charge, and a sentence imposed without a finding of guilt. A prior strike is established through official records rather than a police report or a prosecutor’s shorthand. The court may examine the judgment, the record of conviction, the underlying case documents and any testimony needed to resolve a genuine dispute. Prop 36 also preserves a hearing right for people seeking relief and gives the court authority to obtain records and compel witnesses. The precise procedure varies with the stage of the case and the issues in dispute.
For an Australian audience, the terminology can feel unfamiliar because California uses “strike” as a sentencing classification. Australian courts also consider previous convictions, but through state or federal sentencing statutes and parole law rather than Prop 36’s framework. Familiar ideas about conviction records, judicial reasons and legal representation in Sydney, Melbourne and other Australian cities can help readers follow the process, although California statutes control every issue. Advice on an individual case must come from a lawyer authorised in California.
What the court must establish
The starting point is the serious-felony list in section 1192.7(c) of the California Penal Code. A previous conviction counts as a qualifying strike only if the offence falls within the statutory categories; the first two qualifying convictions can create strike status. The current conviction must also be nonviolent for ordinary Prop 36 relief. Statutory exclusions can still apply, including to offences involving manifestly dangerous conduct, so the label “nonviolent” is not the only test.
That distinction matters because the three offences need not be identical. A robbery conviction, for example, can supply a serious-felony strike even if the current offence is a different kind of nonviolent felony. The court must identify the statutory basis for the conviction, its final disposition and the basis for the finding of guilt. A conviction later reduced on appeal or set aside must be assessed in light of that later outcome.
The court is not deciding whether the old sentence was fair in hindsight. It is applying the statutory definition to historical events. Likewise, a current prison sentence does not by itself show that the person is dangerous within the meaning of the exclusion. Where the People assert facts that would make an inmate ineligible, Prop 36 assigns them the burden of establishing those disqualifying facts. The person seeking relief must still establish the eligibility the statute requires.
Building a reliable conviction record
An abstract of judgment is often the most useful starting point, but it may not answer every question. Counsel may also need certified copies of charging documents, pleas, jury verdicts, findings, dismissal orders and sentencing records. For older convictions, the court reporter’s transcript can reveal what actually happened. Records held by a county, another state or the federal system must be obtained as well. The central task is to connect each earlier case to the same person and preserve a traceable chain of official documents.
Not every document proves every element. A docket can show a case number and a status, while the judgment shows the disposition and the sentence; a plea transcript may identify the admitted facts. The court needs enough information to match the conviction against the serious-felony categories and determine whether an exception applies. If an earlier case cannot be located, the parties cannot responsibly treat a database entry as a complete answer. A missing record is an evidentiary problem to resolve, not an invitation to assume the worst or the best.
Families often face the hardest task in obtaining old records rather than reading them. The case preparation resources published by the Fix Three Strikes Resource Centre explain how a loved one can organise a conviction history and prepare for a legal review. These resources can complement, but not replace, a lawyer’s check of the underlying files. The resulting chronology should list case numbers, offence dates, conviction dates, sentences and any later orders in one place.
Resolving disputes at a hearing
A hearing may become necessary where the parties disagree about what an earlier conviction was, whether a document is authentic or whether the statutory conditions are satisfied. A person seeking relief has the right to testify and present witnesses, and the court may issue subpoenas for records or witnesses. Judicial notice can sometimes authenticate a certified record. If accuracy is challenged, however, the party relying on the record must be able to support it, and live evidence may be required.
The standard of proof depends on the issue being decided. A contested fact that increases the seriousness of punishment or triggers a statutory disqualification must be proved beyond a reasonable doubt; simple uncertainty is not enough to treat an allegation as established. Prop 36 specifically puts the burden of establishing disqualifying facts on the People. This protects the integrity of the original conviction while preventing the sentencing court from expanding its disqualification through guesswork.
A hearing is not a retrial of the original case, and successful proof of two strikes does not guarantee release. It establishes the threshold for the remedy the person seeks. The court may then consider eligible conduct, the sentence’s legal limits and the statutory sentencing factors. Depending on the conviction and sentencing history, relief may mean a reduced term, entry into parole supervision, or a request for resentencing. The outcome depends on the statute governing that path.
Reading the process through Australian law
Australian readers should not assume that a California “strike” maps neatly onto a local rule. Commonwealth sentencing law recognises previous convictions under section 531 of the Crimes Act 1900, while New South Wales, Victoria, Queensland and other states apply their own sentencing and parole legislation. A NSW Supreme Court or District Court judge, for instance, commonly works from a certificate of conviction and a transcript of sentencing reasons when a prior record affects sentence. The terminology resembles a familiar process, but the governing law is different.
Melbourne offers another useful comparison. The Supreme Court of Victoria publishes sentencing outcomes and reasons, and the Sentencing Advisory Council’s SACStat portal gives access to statewide sentencing statistics. Lawyers there may point a client to published sentences when explaining the likely approach to a disputed issue, just as counsel in California may examine prior decisions. These are comparative aids, not proof of how a California judge must decide a particular eligibility hearing.
The local market also shapes where legal help comes from. A practitioner admitted in New South Wales or Victoria may explain Australian procedure, but California-authorised counsel is normally required for advice and representation in the California proceeding. Australian assistance may still be valuable for obtaining archived records, understanding affidavits and supporting a family. The legal precinct around the Victorian Supreme Court in Melbourne and major NSW courts illustrate a practical divide: local proximity does not create local jurisdiction.
Release practices differ too. Victoria uses community correction orders for some offences, while NSW uses parole and parole orders in appropriate cases. Neither should be treated as a synonym for Proposition 36 relief. An Australian offender seeking advice about a California sentence needs the law, procedural stage and available remedy identified before comparing any local supervision option.
Public safety and the value of shorter terms
The purpose of proving prior strikes is not to maximise incarceration automatically. It is to identify accurately the cases eligible for a sentencing structure that separates serious or dangerous offending from nonviolent offences. Prop 36 was designed to reduce the number of people serving life without parole for conduct that does not meet that description. Precise proof serves both sides of that policy: it preserves severe treatment where the statute requires it and prevents a mislabelled conviction from defeating lawful relief.
The public-safety argument rests on the limited evidence available to sentencing courts. The analysis of evidence on shorter sentences supports the case that shorter terms for nonviolent crime need not produce a corresponding rise in serious offending. Longer confinement can be expensive and can disrupt employment, housing and family support without reliably identifying which people will reoffend violently. A more proportionate sentence can allow supervision and reintegration to do work that a long prison term cannot.
Financial arguments are relevant but not decisive. Redirecting some custody costs toward victims’ services, treatment and community supervision may also produce long-term savings, although each claim depends on the population, sentence length and cost assumptions being examined. Evidence must not be stretched into a promise that every shorter sentence is safer or cheaper. The more defensible claim is that fixed, sweeping life sentences can consume substantial public resources while providing little information about an individual’s future conduct.
For a person serving a long term, the evidentiary phase can determine whether reform is available at all. A correctly assembled record permits the court to identify two qualifying prior convictions, apply the exclusions and decide the appropriate path to review. A defective record, by contrast, can delay that decision and leave an eligible person without the remedy the law contemplates. Accuracy therefore serves both public safety and the prisoner’s interests.
The point to remember is simple: a prior strike rests on a documented conviction, its statutory classification and proof of any disputed disqualifying fact. The label alone proves nothing. Accurate findings protect the original judgments, place the burden of disqualification where the statute requires it, and allow the court to impose the appropriate remedy. That is the standard that matters: documented eligibility, not assumption or rhetoric.