Prop. 36 Will:

  • ELIMINATE unintended and ineffective life sentences currently imposed for nonviolent, non-serious crimes
  • RESTORE the original intent and core purpose of the Three Strikes law: to keep dangerous and violent criminals behind bars.
  • SAVE $100 million per year to fund schools, prevent crime, and decrease the need for tax increases.

For Relief Under Prop. 36:

We are working closely with Public Defender offices and other service providers throughout the state to provide the best possible assistance for anyone eligible for relief under Prop. 36.

Click here for resources.

Why We Won

How California Measures Savings From Three Strikes Reform

California’s Three Strikes law was designed to impose severe sentences on repeat offenders, especially people convicted of serious or violent crimes. Proposition 36 changed that framework by narrowing when a third strike could result in life imprisonment. The reform focused on preserving the toughest penalties for dangerous offenders while allowing some people convicted of nonviolent, non-serious offences to seek shorter sentences or resentencing. Learn more about The Story Of The Man Who Spent 20 Years In Prison For A Nonviolent Third Strike.

For an Australian audience, the central issue is how a public auditor turns that legal change into a dollar figure. The calculation is not based on a single invoice or a simple count of prisoners released. It combines prison population data, court records, parole costs, correctional budgets, projected release dates and assumptions about future offending.

That makes the result closer to a financial model than a cash register total. Some savings appear quickly when fewer people remain in prison. Other savings develop over years through reduced healthcare, supervision and legal administration costs. The auditor must also subtract expenses connected with resentencing, parole monitoring and any additional public-safety measures.

The same approach can be useful when comparing California’s policy debate with Australian discussions about sentencing, prison capacity and justice spending. Whether the setting is Los Angeles or Melbourne, a credible estimate must distinguish between money removed from a government budget and broader social benefits that are harder to price.

Identifying The Population Affected

The first step is to identify which prisoners are legally affected by the reform. Auditors examine convictions, criminal histories, sentence lengths and the nature of the third-strike offence. A person serving a life term for a qualifying nonviolent offence may be treated differently from someone whose third strike involved robbery with serious injury or another offence excluded by the reform.

This requires more than searching for the words “third strike” in a database. Case files may contain multiple charges, enhancements, plea agreements and sentencing decisions. The auditor generally works with the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation, courts, prosecutors and parole authorities to reconcile those records and create a reliable eligible population.

The estimate may begin with the number of people who appear eligible for resentencing, then narrow that figure after judicial review. Some people will be denied relief because their record includes a disqualifying offence. Others may already be close to release, making the financial effect smaller than the headline prison count suggests.

Eligibility is therefore a legal and statistical filter. If the starting population is overstated, projected savings will be overstated as well. A careful audit records each exclusion and explains why a person was removed from the savings calculation.

Establishing The Pre-Reform Baseline

A savings estimate needs a baseline: a reasonable forecast of what would have happened if the law had remained unchanged. For each affected prisoner, analysts may calculate the expected years remaining under the original sentence. They then compare those years with the likely period in custody after resentencing.

The baseline can include imprisonment, medical care, disability services, food, transport, security, education and facility maintenance. California’s correctional costs are influenced by the age of the prison population, staffing levels and the location of facilities. Older prisoners often generate higher healthcare costs, so the value of an earlier release may be greater for some people than for others.

Auditors also consider whether the baseline prison cost is a full economic cost or a marginal cost. A full cost includes a share of prison administration and infrastructure. A marginal cost asks how much the state can actually avoid when one person leaves custody. If a prison remains open and staff numbers do not change, the immediate budget reduction may be limited.

This distinction matters to Australian readers familiar with large public systems. Releasing a prisoner from a facility in Sydney or Brisbane would not automatically close a prison wing or eliminate every associated employee. Some expenses are fixed in the short term, while others can be reduced as population levels fall across a broader system.

Calculating Direct Prison Savings

The most visible part of the calculation is the cost of keeping someone in custody. Analysts multiply the expected number of custody days avoided by an appropriate daily cost. The daily figure may include general prison operations, healthcare, meals, transport, clothing, security and prisoner programming.

The model must account for timing. A person released in the first year produces a different result from someone who would have remained in prison for another 15 years. Savings are often reported by financial year, so the auditor allocates each person’s avoided costs to the year in which they would otherwise have occupied a prison bed.

The financial cost analysis associated with prosecuting third-strike cases also helps explain why prison costs are only one part of the picture. Courts, public defenders, prosecutors, probation staff and correctional agencies all spend resources before and after a sentence is imposed.

A sound calculation separates gross savings from net savings. Gross savings represent costs that may be avoided. Net savings subtract the new expenses created by reform, including resentencing hearings, legal representation, parole supervision, treatment programmes and transitional support.

Including Court, Parole And Administrative Costs

Resentencing creates an initial workload. Courts must review applications, prosecutors may respond, defence lawyers may gather records and judges must determine whether a reduced sentence is appropriate. Clerks, probation departments and correctional agencies may also need to update records and release plans.

Those activities can reduce savings in the early years. An auditor may estimate the number of hearings, the average staff time per matter and the cost of legal services. The estimate can then be spread across several budget periods rather than treating every expense as occurring immediately.

Parole and community supervision require a similar treatment. A person who leaves prison may still be supervised, tested, required to attend treatment or subject to electronic monitoring. These services are generally cheaper than imprisonment, but they are not free. The net benefit comes from the difference between the two forms of public spending.

An auditor may also include transitional housing, health referrals and employment assistance where those services are funded by government. This is particularly important when release is expected to reduce the risk of homelessness or repeated custody. The calculation should state clearly whether such spending is counted as a cost, a benefit or outside the model.

Cost Categories In The Estimate

  • Prison operations and prisoner healthcare
  • Court hearings and publicly funded legal work
  • Parole, treatment and community supervision
  • Transport, records management and release planning

Modelling Release Rates And Behaviour

A legal entitlement to seek resentencing does not mean every eligible person will leave prison immediately. Some people may not apply, some applications may be refused and some approved releases may occur months or years after the reform begins. The auditor therefore uses release-rate assumptions to estimate when savings will appear.

Behaviour after release is another important variable. If a released person remains in the community without a new serious offence, the state avoids future imprisonment costs. If the person is later arrested and returned to custody, some of those savings disappear. The calculation may use historical recidivism data, parole outcomes and the age and risk profile of the affected population.

This is where estimates can become politically contentious. Supporters of reform may emphasise the high cost of long-term imprisonment and the limited public-safety value of life sentences for nonviolent offences. Critics may focus on the financial and social consequences of a serious reoffence. An auditor’s role is to make the assumptions visible rather than choose rhetoric over evidence.

The story of a man who spent decades in prison for a nonviolent third strike illustrates why individual cases matter in public debate, but one case cannot establish the average fiscal outcome. Auditors use thousands of records, tested assumptions and sensitivity analysis to prevent an unusually expensive or unusually successful case from distorting the overall forecast.

Testing Assumptions And Uncertainty

A reliable report usually presents more than one scenario. The central forecast might use the most likely release rate and reoffending rate. A conservative scenario could assume slower resentencing, higher supervision costs or more returns to custody. An optimistic scenario might assume faster court processing and lower long-term imprisonment costs.

Sensitivity testing shows which assumptions have the greatest influence. If a small change in the daily prison cost produces a large change in estimated savings, that figure deserves close scrutiny. The same applies to the expected number of eligible prisoners, the average time remaining on sentence and the proportion who return to prison.

Auditors may discount future savings because money saved ten years from now is worth less in present terms than money saved this year. Discounting is common in government financial analysis and allows projected costs and benefits to be compared on a consistent basis. The report should disclose the discount rate and explain how inflation is handled.

Results should also be checked against actual budget movements. If a forecast predicts major savings but prison staffing, healthcare expenditure and facility costs remain unchanged, the difference may reflect fixed costs or delayed implementation. That does not automatically invalidate the reform, but it does show why projected savings and realised savings are separate measures.

Questions Used To Check The Model

  • How many prisoners qualify under the statutory definition?
  • How quickly can courts process resentencing applications?
  • Which prison costs fall when the population declines?
  • How often do released people return to custody?

Applying The Legal Definition Correctly

The legal boundary between a qualifying nonviolent offence and a serious or violent felony is central to the calculation. An offence that appears minor in everyday language may carry aggravating facts, weapon enhancements or a statutory classification that changes eligibility. The audit therefore relies on the law as interpreted by courts, not on informal descriptions of crimes.

The definition of a serious felony is especially important because a classification error can affect both public-safety analysis and projected savings. Including an ineligible prisoner inflates the estimated number of releases. Excluding a qualifying prisoner understates the reform’s potential effect and may hide the cost of continued imprisonment.

Legal changes after the original reform can also alter the model. Court decisions, amendments, resentencing rules and changes to parole policy may affect how many people qualify and how quickly they leave custody. A responsible auditor records the law in force during the period studied and updates projections when the legal environment changes.

This attention to definitions has a practical Australian parallel. Australian states and territories use different offence categories, sentencing rules and parole systems, so a prison-cost estimate in New South Wales cannot simply be transferred to Victoria or Queensland. Local legislation must determine the eligible group before any financial comparison is meaningful.

Reading The Final Savings Figure

The final figure generally combines several components: avoided prison costs, reduced court and administrative activity, continuing supervision costs, transitional spending and possible future custody costs. The result may be expressed as annual savings, total savings over a fixed period or a present-value estimate covering several decades.

It is useful to ask what the number actually represents. A claim of millions of dollars in savings may mean lower long-term government costs, not an immediate cheque returned to taxpayers. It may also include costs that disappear only if the prison population falls enough for the state to reduce staffing, close units or defer construction.

For people comparing policy debates in California with everyday budget questions in Australia, the distinction is familiar. A household in Perth may spend less on petrol after changing vehicles, but the saving depends on kilometres travelled, fuel prices and finance costs. Likewise, a correctional reform produces a real fiscal benefit only when the avoided custody period exceeds the cost of implementing the alternative.

The most practical way to read an auditor’s estimate is to trace the chain from law to population, from population to release timing, and from release timing to net cost. Check whether the report distinguishes projected from realised savings, states its assumptions and separates immediate budget reductions from long-term economic benefits. That chain provides the clearest test of whether the headline figure reflects a defensible calculation rather than a persuasive slogan.

News

Next Slide Previous Slide